Showing posts with label corruption in judiciary. Show all posts
Showing posts with label corruption in judiciary. Show all posts

Thursday, June 4, 2009

रेफोर्म्स इन क्रिमिनल जस्टिस सिस्टम



TIME TO OPEN EYES

Criminal Justice System in India is a British legacy and had been established by the British Govt. The Indian Penal Code, 1860, Indian Evidence Act, 1871 and Criminal procedure Code of 1898 laid down the foundation stone of Criminal Justice System in India. The police force was created to execute and implement the verdict and bring the culprits to book. Police Act was enacted in 1849 last amended in 1861 to make the police force institutionalised. These above mentioned laws marked the beginning of evolution of Criminal Justice System in Modern India.
India became independent and we continued the British legacy. The voice of concerns against police apathy and atrocities gaining strength and it became gradually lauder. With the passage of time the system of governance and priorities of government underwent changes. The welfare state concept, human rights ethos as declared in Universal Declaration of Human rights by the UN on 10th December, 1948 etc necessitated drastic changes in the prevailing and exiting monolith structure of Criminal Justice System in our country.
The Criminal Justice System includes two aspect of Justice-
1. Police. 2. Judiciary
POLICE- Police being the most important and most visible part of Criminal Justice System, it was required to be revamped. The vestiges of British legacies were sought to be done away with by making it more people’s friendly, more responsive and more responsible. To achieve this desired goal and reform the structure one National Police Commission was constituted in 1977 by Ministry of Home affairs which gave recommendation on Police reforms.
NATIONAL POLICE COMMISSION-(1977-81) This commission was set up on 15 November, 1977 headed by Dharam Vira ICS, The commission gave as many as 8(eight) recommendation, last was submitted in 1981. Unfortunately none of the recommendations were implemented by any state. Important recommendation of this commission are-
· Police complaint Board as state level
· Posting of DGP from panel prepared by a committee comprising of UPSC chairman, CS and officers of MOH
· State security commission
· Gram Nyayalaya ( village courts)
· DGP would chose SPs and SPs would choose SHOs.
· APP& Additional PP on regular basis.
· Cadre of investigating officers should be increased.
· Directorate of Prosecution at state level and Deputy Director at regional level.
· Police stations as whole and compact unit (catering to all needs like traffic, Law and Order, Crime etc.
· Urban areas should have exclusive police stations.
· 150 sq KM should have one PS in rural areas
Unfortunately none except Sikkim implemented all such recommendation.
Prakash Singh retired IPS filed a petition in the Apex court and Supreme Court in its judgement (Writ Petition 310/1996) passed order on 11 January 2007. It has now become the guiding principle of police reforms in India.
The main points of judgement is as follows-
1. Establishment of a National Security Commission- this was for the Union Govt.
2. Establishment of a State Security Commission- this direction was for the State govt.
3. Selection of DGP from a panel and its fixation of tenure.
4. Minimum tenure of IGP to other field level officers.
5. Separation of Law and Order from investigation.
6. Police establishment board.
7. Constitution of Complaint Authority.
In pursuance of the above direction Government of Bihar enacted Bihar Police Act, 2007 in the year 2007 and repealed the relevant part of provisions of Police Act, 1861. State of Bihar took lead in this direction and incorporated some of the directions given by the Supreme Court. In section 59 of the act, the police department at district level has been made answerable to district complaint authority. Keeping in view of the spirit of judgment delivered by the apex court in Prakash Singh v/s Union of India, a civil officer, the district magistrate has been made chairman of this complaint authority.
The Act has yet not been fully enforced in the sense that till date Rules to this effect has not been framed. Section 94 of the Act empowers the Govt to frame Rules; non framing thereto has hampered the enforcement of this Act.

REFORMS IN CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM (JUDICIAL SIDE)
The first serious attempt was made in 2000 when Ministry of Home affairs constituted a committee on 24 November, 2000 under the chairmanship of Justice V.S. Mallimath, retired Chief Justice of Karnataka High Court and Kerala High Courts. Eminent legal luminaries like Chairman CAT, Member of NHRC were made members of this committee which is popularly known as MALLIMATH COMMITTEE.
TERMS OF REFERENCES-
· Suggest fundamental principle of Criminal Jurisprudence.
· Need to rewrite Criminal Procedure Code, Indian Penal Code, IEA etc
· Simplifying procedure for dispensation of speedy justice and simplifying complications in Criminal jurisprudence.
· Suggest ways and means developing synergy among Police, Judiciary, and Prosecution.
· Concept of federal crime in List I of seventh schedule so that heinous crimes can be removed from state list and bought to Union list I( article 246 of Indian Constitution)
Recommendations of Malimath committee-

1- Striking a balance between adversarial and inquisitorial system of investigation. The latter being supervised by a judicial magistrate.
2- Restriction to right to silence. This fundamental right is enshrined in Article 22 (3) of constitution which confers the accused the right to keep mum in eliciting information to a prosecution during examination.
3- Justice to victims. Present day criminal jurisprudence is based on the concept of awarding punishment to a accused to other than providing relief and succour to the victims. Committee recommended for awarding adequate compensation to the victims apart from awarding punishments only.
4- Separation of investigation and law and order wing of the police on line of NPC.
5- Special legislations to be enacted for organized crime, economic offences, Terrorism and low intensity war.
6- Concept of Federal Crime to be inserted Criminal jurisprudence and should be brought in list I of schedule VII in Article 246 on Indian Constitution on lines of America.
FADE OF MALIMATH COMMITTE’S RECOMENDATION –
Like many other recommendations of numerous committee and commission, 158 recommendations of this committee also mat the same fade। Majority of the recommendations have been thrown into the dust bins. Bihar is one such state which has partially acted on lines of these recommendations and has in acted Bihar Police Act 2007 repealing some of the out dated, vestigial and obsolete provisions of Police Act 1861.

MAJOR CHALLANGES FACING INDIAN JUDICIAL SYSTEM –
1। Huge pendency of cases (3, 63, 36,000) in different courts.

2। Inordinate delay in disposal of cases.

3। Ill –prioritisation of cases. The listing of cases are still done, despite computerisation , in most unscientific and non transparent manner

4। The quality and quantity of judgement are affected not by quality of judgement rather than personalities of the lawyers. Jungle of rulings has swallowed the bare Acts Codes.

5। Appointment procedures of High Court and Supreme Court Judges are not institutionalised (Advocate on record versus Union of India case in 1994 Supreme Court of India)

6. The impeachment procedure of High Court and Supreme Court Judges is arduous and complicated. This has led to development of an idea that judges can never be sacked. (The case of Justice Soumitra Sen, the judge of Calcutta High Court is still to be taken up in the Parliament.

Monday, November 3, 2008

INQUIRY COMMISSIONS ARE BLACK HOLES IN INDIA


iGovernment » Governance Inquiry Commissions in India are black holes

Nanawti Commission report on the Godhara incident has once again opened the Pandora's Box over logic of setting up Inquiry Commissions in India

Published on 10/3/2008 7:10:07 PM
By Sarita Yadav

Part one of the Nanawti Commission report, probing into the Godhara incident in Gujarat, released last month has once again opened the Pandora's Box over logic of setting up Inquiry Commissions in the country.

The report while giving clean chit to the Narendra Modi Government has supported the theory of conspiracy, leading to a widespread criticism across the country.

Many call it 'eye wash' and other call it 'sponsored report'. Communists have termed it a 'piecemeal' and fabricated report, whereas; National Democratic Alliance (NDA) calls it 'triumph of truth'.

Justice Nanawati report in fact contradicts the UC Banerjee report which also probed the Godhara incident. How a single incident draws two extreme conclusions?

The two reports have raised a very debatable issue. What do judicial commissions, appointed by the various governments to examine issues ranging from riots, scandals and assassinations to inter-state disputes actually achieve?

Critics of commissions say that their recent history has been extremely spotty. Apart from taking inordinately long to deliver reports, they seldom achieve anything.

Keeping apart from such allegations and counter allegations, the issue that has again come to fore is whether an inquiry commission can substitute criminal prosecution?

Do these Commissions serve any purpose? Is it not an eye wash? Are these Commissions able to bring culprits to book? Are not Commissions of inquiry a waste of time and money?

To understand the entire issue, one has to discuss the Commission of Inquiry Act, 1952 itself. Before this Act came into being, the governments used to order an inquiry by executive notifications under Public Service Inquiry Act, 1850. Sometimes, they used to enact adhoc and temporary legislations too.

To meet the public demand for impartial and judicial inquiries, the Government of India came out with a comprehensive legislation, which resulted into passage of this Commission of Inquiry Act, 1952.

Since its enactment, the constitution of Inquiry Commissions has become a tool for the various governments to subside the public anger.

Since Independence, more than a hundred Inquiry Commissions have been set up, but a very few have served the purpose. And the reasons are obvious. First, the provisions enshrined in this Act are not of deterrent in nature and secondly, most of the time the Commissions are set up under retired Judges for obvious reasons.

Section 4 the Act provides for powers and it is clear that the Commission has no power to compel a person to adduce before it and give evidence. It cannot pass verdicts or judgments which could be enforceable.

The helplessness is such that even if an offence has been committed in view of or in presence of Commission, the Commission needs to forward the case to the Magistrate for trial as provided in Criminal Procedure code.

The appointment of retired Judges, as head of the Commission is very much suitable for the government. It is not merely a chance that one Judge has headed more than one Commission. The public perception is such that these Inquiry Commissions are becoming post retirement placement schemes for the favourite retired Judges.

We have a long list of such Commissions, which have made inordinate delay in submitting their reports. Many of them have taken decades in so called "conducting inquiries" and even then the report which was submitted were so voluminous that we required another committee to find out ways to implement the recommendations.

For example, as many as ten Commissions or committees have so far been set up with regard to the anti-Sikh riots in Delhi after the assassination of former Prime Minister Indira Gandhi.

First of all it was the Marvah Commission headed by Additional Commissioner of Police Ved Marvah, that was set up in November, 1984.

The Commission was about to finish the assigned task when it was abruptly wounded up in May 1985 and a new Commission headed by Justice Rangnath Misra was constituted. The new Commission was asked to carry out further inquiry hitherto done by the Marvah Commission.

The Justice Ranganath Mishra Commission which was appointed under Section 3 of The Commissions of Inquiry Act, 1952, was asked to inquire into "allegations" of violence and not to inquire into the "nature" of violence, a departure from the terms of reference of over a dozen other commissions on communal disturbances since Independence.

It is needless to mention that what has happened to reports and how much amount have been spent on these exercises. Has any prominent leader been punished so far? Many persons, against whom leveled charges were being inquired into, have died. Such are the frustrating results of these Commissions and Committees.

As far as time and money aspect of these Commissions are concerned, its enough to look into the expenses of just couple of Commissions to understand the quantum of impact—both in terms of the amount and time spent.

The one that tops the chart is the Liberhan Commission. Set up under retired Justice M S Liberhan on 16 December, 1992 to probe into Babri mosque demolition, the Commission has so far been given more than 41 extensions. Overall the government has already spent Rs 90 million on this single man inquiry Commission, which is yet to come out with its report.

Similarly, Justice B N Kripal Commission of inquiry was set up on 13 July, 1985 to probe into the bombing of the Air India Flight 182 on 23 June, 1985 which led to the crash of this plane into the Atlantic Ocean leaving 329 passengers including crew dead.

The Commission submitted its report after extensive tours of countries like Canada and USA but when the prosecution began, nothing could be proved and none could be punished. The entire 'investigation and inquiry' went in vain. It is needless again, to calculate the amount which was spent on such inquiries.

Phukan Commission was set up to probe the Tehelka expose into fictitious defence deals. Everyone saw the tape on television and the then Government just to avoid immediate legal course, set up this Commission.

In May 2005 the Newsweek reported that Justice Phukan along with his wife and eight officials used IAF plane and went to Pune, Mumbai and Shirdi. The Ministry later said that the Judge was not entitled to use the military plane and it was made available to him by the then government in order to influence the Judge.

Such allegations and incidents definitely erode public faith in such Commissions. The situation is such that every Government in power uses this provision to oblige the retired judges.

In Bihar for example, Justice Amir Das Commission was set up to probe into the alleged connections of political leaders with a banned outfit called Ranveer Sena in 1997.

The Commission was finally wounded up in 2006 as it could hardly do anything except for some tours and recording the statements some leaders in over eight years of its existence.

Similar is the case of Justice Ali Ahmed Commission that was set up to look into excess withdrawal in 1996. In fact, very little is known about the outcome of the Commission, including the recommendations that it submited or the actions taken by it.

Commission under Justice R C P Sinha and Justice Samsul was set up on Bhagalpur communal riot in 1989. Reports were submitted in 1995. But when the new government came to power it set up N N Singh (retired Justice) Commission to investigate the matter again.

In 2008 a Commission under retired judge Sadanand Mukherjee was set up to probe into the Kahalgaon police firing. This commission is still a non starter vis-a-vis investigation of the incidence.

Not to miss the fact that when the recent breach in Kosi embankment that caused a major flood in Bihar led to lot of allegations and counter allegations, the state government was quick to constitute a Commission under Rajesh Walia, again a retired Judge to probe into it.

And while there is no bias against the judiciary or the retired judges, who are a national repository of knowledge as far as judicial matters are concerned, the question needs to be examined is whether a Commission can substitute the country's criminal investigation system.

How can a Judge be better equipped to do forensic test, do scientific investigations than a professionally trained police officer? Has the Commission power to make arrests to the persons likely to tamper evidences?

The answer to these and many such questions has been provided by a two Judge commission itself. Set up by in 1987 to investigate the Fairfax Deal, the Justice Thakkar and Natarajan Commission in its report have said that the Commission of Inquiry Act was "ineffective and toothless". They two, in fact, devoted one full chapter on the inadequacies of this Act.

It is important to note that India has a criminal justice system, which is based on the twin pillars of investigation and dispensation of justice. How can the Judiciary be asked to do the work of investigation, which is the work of the State as enshrined the law of the land?

The Criminal Procedure Code and for that matter entire Criminal Justice System is erected on this principle (Article 50 of Chapter IV on Directive Principles of State Policy) and perhaps it is due to this principle, that the judiciary and executive have been completely separated in 1973, when the Code of Criminal Procedure was amended.

Besides, most of these Commissions, after years of its investigation, usually submit reports that are so voluminous that it again requires some committees to suggest measures to implements the recommendations.

Not to talk about the fact that such reports are not obligatory and mandatory for the government to implement.

It is also worthwhile to mention here that the Judiciary in India is an independent system and that is precisely the reason why Article 220 restricts practise by retired Judges. The idea is that there should not be any scope, whatsoever, of favour or disfavour by the serving Judges.

By appointing the retired Judges in these Commissions or for that matter in any other body tends to clearly violate the spirit of the Constitution itself.

What is more shocking is that instead of modernising and equipping the investigating agencies to probe into such serious issues of national shame, the country has been a mere spectator to the cosmetic make ups.

In India, every one knows about the 'normal' pace of the court proceedings, and so all these commissions, needless to say have virtually become black holes.
—Views expressed in this article are of the author and not those of iGovernment


Email PrintShare
Post Comments Total Comments: 9
Posted By Vimal Kr on 10/4/2008 8:58:49 AM
What about the Rajesh Walia commission. Even a man of common intellect understands that the breach was caused due to utter negligence of the govt. then why a commission? Is it not an eye wash? Why only retired Judge. Kahalgaon police firing commission was also set up to save a IAS officer and an IPS officer who are favourite of govt. The writer should mention about these commission also.

Posted By Gajendra Kr Singh on 10/4/2008 11:52:42 AM
What an excellent article on commission of inquiry. It is clearly an eye wash and nothing more than that. These commissions have become post retirement engagements and the govt awards the favorite judges by appointing them in such institutions. It should be stopped. After all institutions are bigger than the individuals.

Posted By Mantu on 10/4/2008 12:13:00 PM
Wonderfull article and an eye opener also. It is shocking that how the public money is being misutilised. It should be stopped or provisions should be made so that it is made mandatory to submit the report on time or else no payment would be made.

Posted By Abhimanyu on 10/4/2008 7:12:35 PM
I went through your article and it was excellent and informative. It is shocking to know that after an elapse of 16 years the liberhan commission has not submitted its report. What a wastage of public money?

Posted By S. Kumar on 10/7/2008 1:09:10 PM
These inquiry commissions are eating up the state's exchequer. It is said the Judge never retires. They have systematically constructed so many institutions for themselves so that they may get post retirement engagements. Press council, NHRC, NMC, tribunals, backward commissions, information commissions, SC ST commissions etc are nothing but post retirement placement bureau. Shut it down or make transparent system of appointment.


Posted By Mantu on 10/7/2008 2:07:01 PM
Is the commission fails to submit its report in time, the pays and perks should not be given. Once they are appointed, they go on getting extensions and continue to enjoy the facilities. It is high of hypocryacy. It should stop. the judges should refrain from doing such things other wise they will loose respect.

Posted By Suresh Kr Intara on 10/7/2008 3:17:06 PM
Very good article and an eye opener also. It is shocking that how the public money is being misutilised. It should be stopped or provisions should be made so that it is made mandatory to submit the report on time or else no payment would be made.

Posted By Sanket on 10/7/2008 7:23:03 PM
Excellent stuff and lots of facts are depicted. Bihar govt should look at these facts and bring them into action. System should be much more transparent to the public.

Posted By Maneesh Ranjan on 10/9/2008 6:16:14 PM
What a shame of our system. It is very shocking to know how the public money is being misutilised? Fix responsibility and say perform or perish. Why crores of cases are lying pending why judges are not disposing them. It easy preaching than done.

SACKING GOVERNMENT EASIER THAN REMOVING A JUDGE IN INIDIA


iGovernment » Governance Sacking govt easier than removing judges in India
Transparency International in its 2007 report said Judiciary in India was the third most corrupt institutions. Recent instances seem proving it

Published on 9/16/2008 3:33:35 PM
By Sarita Yadav

The letter written by the Chief Justice of India (CJI) to the Prime Minister seeking his intervention in initiating impeachment proceedings against a sitting judge of Calcutta High Court, has triggered a debate again regarding corruption in higher judiciary and its impunity.

We have seen removal of governments and Prime Ministers so many times, but removal of High Court and Supreme Court judges has not been so far heard after the Constitution of India came into force in 1950.

Independent India has, however, witnessed one impeachment, when Justice Shiv Prasad Sinha of Allahabad High Court was removed by the then Governor General of India, C Rajagopalachari in 1949 on the recommendation of the Federal Court.

The Chief Justice has given detailed information about Justice Sen's misconduct when he was appointed receiver by Justice AN Roy in Steel Authority of India versus Shipping Corporation of India case in 1993.

The three-Judge panel comprising Madras High Court Chief Justice AP Shah, MP High Court Chief Justice AK Patnaik and Rajasthan High Court Chief Justice RM Lodha inquired into the charges leveled against Justice Sen and found them true. 

The panel submitted its report in February, 2008. On March 16, the Collegiums of the apex court comprising of Chief Justice BN Agarwal and Justice Asok Bhan asked Justice Sen either to resign or to opt for voluntary retirement.

However, with Justice Sen deciding not to comply with either of the two options, the Chief Justice was forced to resort to this unprecedented move.

The move is unprecedented, because neither there is any provision in the constitution about such recommendation nor before this, any Chief Justice has taken such 'extreme step'. 

In fact Article 124(4) of Indian Constitution provides for removal of High Court and Supreme Court Judges. 

The Article says: “A judge of Supreme Court shall not be removed from his office except by an order of the President passed after an address by each House of Parliament supported by a majority of the total number of membership of that House and by a majority of not less than two-thirds of the members of that House present and voting has been presented to the President in the same session for such removal on the ground of proved misbehaviour or incapacity.”

There is no separate provision for removal of High Court judges and Article 217(1)(b) provides for this and says, “A judge may be removed from his office by the President in the manner provided in clause(4) of Article 124 for the removal of a judge of the Supreme Court.”

The processes of removal of High Court and Supreme Court judges are the same. The above Article of the Constitution provides for impeachment, whereas; Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968 determines the process of impeachment. 

According to this Act, the impeachment of a judge can be done only by Parliament and impeachment can be initiated after a motion addressed to the President of India is signed by at least 100 members of the Lok sabha or 50 members of Rajya Sabha.

Such is the process and such is the impunity. Such Judicial impunity has been conferred on Judiciary for the sake of its independence.

The above provision is similar to the rule prevailing in England, since the Act of Settlement, 1701, to the effect that though judges of the superior courts are appointed by the Crown, they do not hold office during his pleasure, but hold their office on good behaviour and the Crown may remove them based on a joint address from both the Houses of Parliament.

Any way the credit must be given to Chief Justice, who could take such extra-ordinary step, because after all, extra-ordinary situation demands extra-ordinary steps.

But unfortunately, the government was sitting over it as it was written two months ago and could only be known to public through media. 

Before any debate on this issue, it should be clearly borne in mind that above cumbersome procedure of impeachment and other judicial impunities have been enshrined in the Constitution for making Judiciary independent. 

Independence of Judiciary
The independence is guaranteed in our Constitution and the concept has been borrowed from the US Constitution. Article III of US Constitution guarantees Independence and Supremacy of Judiciary in the US. 

Independence of Judiciary is the tenet of democracy and therefore, even Russian Constitution of 1993 (Chapter-7 Section 120-122) also guarantees independence of Judiciary in the country.

In fact section 124 of the Russian Constitution says, “Judges shall posses immunity and criminal proceedings may not be brought against a Judge except as provided for by federal law.”

In India, this independence and limited Judicial Supremacy are enshrined in the Constitution and are expressed in the methods of appointment of judges; the process of impeachment; and the power of judicial review.

Now, if all these provisions of the Constitution are analysed, inference can easily be drawn that the problems lay here themselves and so do solutions.

The Appointment Rules
Articles 124 and 217 provide for appointment of Judges of Supreme Court and High Court respectively. They clearly stipulate that the appointments have to be made by the President in consultation with the Chief Justice.

The word 'consultation' has been always a matter of dissent and controversy. In fact, when AN Ray was appointed as Chief Justice after superseding three senior Judges namely Hegde, Grover and Shelat, there was uproar in Judicial community including the Bar council of the apex court.

They argued that judges have been superseded owing to their judgement in Keshavanand case (AIR 1973 Supreme Court) which went against the government. 

Gradually the direction of Executive in matters of appointment of judges started diminishing. In 1993, a land mark judgment came from Supreme Court in 'Advocates on record versus Union of India' case. 

The apex court ruled that the recommendations for appointment of Judges in High Court and Supreme Court will be made by collegiums of three Judges and shall be in a way binding on the government.

After a 'presidential reference', the number in the collegiums was increased from three to five. 

This judgment was a landmark because it took virtually all discretionary powers of the Executive in matters of appointment of judges in higher judiciary. Thus, the word 'consultation' became 'concurrence'. 

Some people in legal domain argue that it was a dangerous development and was against the principles of the Constitution itself. How can a person or a group of persons appoint themselves which goes against the ideas enshrined in Article 311? 

They opine that there must be a transparent and justifiable procedure for such appointments. There are instances where persons from one family are becoming Judges for two to three generations.

The judicial community of higher Judiciary is becoming an elite club of few 'privileged families'. Candidly, it is not what 'independence' meant for.

The Impeachment
The process of impeachment as discussed in the article above, clearly indicates that it is a cumbersome process. No wonder then, not a single judge could be removed in India since 1949. 

It may be recalled that in 1991, the impeachment proceedings for removal of Justice V Ramaswami fell flat on its face after members of the Congress party decided to abstain from voting. 

The process of impeachment is laid down in Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968 which says that even if the motion is accepted, the presiding officer of the House has to constitute a three judge committee to further inquire into the matter. 

The process suggests that the motion will be put to voting once again after the submission of the report by the Judges' Committee. However, unlike in the case of a no confidence motion against a government, which requires a simple majority to survive, the impeachment motion against a judge requires a two-third majority.

That is why, it is truly said that it is easier to decide the fate of 100 billion people by way of forming and toppling Governments in India than removing a Judge in the country.

It is also but strange that the country which has seen many a ministers and bureaucrats being convicted on charges of corruption does not have a single incidence of a judge being impeached.

The ‘Transparency International' in its report of 2007 has counted judiciary as the third most corrupt institutions in India, an inference totally in contrary to the common perception that instances of corruption in higher judiciary are not unheard of.

The former CJI Y K Sabarwal himself is in the eyes of storm for his judgement pronounced in the ‘Delhi Sealing Case', which allegedly benefited his son. When a report in this regard appeared in one Newspaper, a suo motto contempt proceeding was initiated and the concerned reporter was sought to be punished.

The Contempt of Court Act, 1971, which itself is not yet codified, is another tool which sometimes is used to gauge the voice of dissent.

In another infamous case, the vigilance department of UP Police exposed misappropriation of funds worth Rs 23 crore from the GPF account of Class III and IV employees of Ghaziabad Civil Court.

One of the accused arrested in this connection, made startling revelation that he has parted the money both in cash and kind, with one sitting Judge of SC, ten Judges of HC and 23 Judges of lower courts.

The investigation is not proceeding as Police cannot interrogate judges without the consent of SC, though such protections are not given in Judges (Inquiry) Act. The matter is still pending with the apex court and the CJI has to convince the nation, whether there is equality before the law or not.

Not to forget the matter of the two Haryana High Court Judges whose names have figured in a case in which a law officer from Haryana has alleged to have sent Rs 15 lakh to them. The Matter has been referred to CBI by the apex court.

The list is long and result is dismally naught. And while one may agree that it is easy preaching than done, the question being asked by common citizen is that who will judge the judges?

The Remedies
• The provisions of RTI should be made applicable to all components of functioning of Judiciary. Accordingly, suitable amendments in RTI Act, 2005 can be made.

• The procedure of selection of Judges should be made more transparent and justifiable. Panel of judges can be made well in advance before recommendation and be known to public by way of websites or media.

• Idea of setting up of a National Judicial Commission can also be made into reality, after all if you are required to go for a test for becoming a clerk, why does selection of judges not require any test. An all India test might also be conducted to select judges of higher judiciary.

• The Government is sitting over the Judges (inquiry) bill, 2006 for more than two years, therefore it should be passed, but before that necessary amendments are required, because the concept of ‘brother judges' doing inquiry has proved ineffective if not futile.

• The contempt of Court Act, 1971 should be suitably amended, because healthy criticism of any institution is generally beneficial for the system itself in the long run. The Judiciary should prepare itself for listening to its criticism and bring about change by itself, a change though painful but helpful.

—The opinion expressed in this article are of the writer and not those of iGovernment



Email PrintShare
Post Comments Total Comments: 13 
Posted By SC Vashishth on 9/17/2008 11:25:52 AM 
It is very humane to be corrupt if there is no public eye and the authority enjoys such impunity! I thoroughly agree with the writer. The suggestions, if implemented, will go a long way in restoring people's faith in the judiciary. At the same time, we have to 
be careful that it is kept beyond the purview of the dirty party politics. 

Regards 

Posted By A.K. Sinha on 9/17/2008 12:46:35 PM 
An article of excellence. The writer has fearlessly expressed her opinion. The constitutional provisions are being misused by the Judges and therefore unnecessary immunities should be done away with.
Asok
Hyderabad 

Posted By gajendra kr singh on 9/18/2008 12:56:16 PM 
The writer has boldly expressed his opinion in a candid manner. The govt and apex court should come up to the expectation of the public. If such institutions are not changing itself with the changing pace of time it will decay. 

Posted By Sanjay Kumar on 9/19/2008 10:38:55 AM 
Before reading this article I was not able to understand this complex issue. The writer has very clearly described the entire process. That is why judges are so fastidious and insensible. Make them accountable and result oriented. Target should be fixed and holidays should be curtailed. The British style of functioning should not be allowed. 

Posted By Murari Pd. Singh on 9/21/2008 11:34:53 AM 
The writer has boldly presented her views on corruption in Judiciary. I am surprised to know the kind of impunity which is given to the judges. Constitutional amendment should be made to make Judiciary more accountable. 

murari 

Posted By Yash Kr Yadav on 9/21/2008 11:51:48 AM 
An eye opener for all those who fight against corruption and justice. Make the judiciary result oriented rather than gimmick oriented. The accountability of judges should be determined in transparent way. 

Yash, Danapur 

Posted By G.Kr on 9/21/2008 1:52:12 PM 
I had not been able to understand the technicality of the matter earlier. Let the common person know about the judicial procedure and impunity and make judges more known to citizen of India 

G. Kr 

Posted By Anindita Dey on 9/21/2008 2:19:27 PM 
There are black sheep in every sphere of life and judiciary may not be the exception. Moreover, the caution of ‘he who fights with monsters should be careful lest he thereby become a monster’ may be very much pertinent to judiciary.
For this, a system of accountability with firm time lines for different categories of cases may be drawn by the Honourable Supreme Court. The rotten bud need to be nipped by judiciary itself to protect the unnecessary gaze of public and media on judiciary and uphold its supremacy. 

Posted By Sapan Roy on 9/23/2008 3:15:16 PM 
I fail to understand how and why one should believe that Judges are incorruptible. The lawers who generally use all means to win a case, when become a Judge suddenly become custodian of Law? Let the Judiciary be made accountable and transparent. File a petition on cricket match telecast and it will be herd next day but the poor men are fighting legal battles for decades and still not herd. Who prioritise the case after all. 

Posted By G. Kr on 10/1/2008 7:58:40 PM 
Let a judicial commission be set up to select and appoint judges. The non transparent method of selection should be discontinued. In Bihar selection is done on the basis of clan not on merit. 

Posted By Vivek on 10/2/2008 12:48:35 PM 
Why govt is scared in removing the judges who are tainted? Manmohan Singh should show courage in setting in the motion in the Lok Sabha against sen and those who are involved in Ghaziabad scam. 

Posted By Mantu on 10/3/2008 12:03:48 PM 
When such charges prima facie comes into light the officer concerned is put under suspension and cases are filed. Why such actions are not taken against them. Is there two law in India. 

Posted By Abhimanyu on 10/4/2008 7:22:58 PM 
Let a selection procedure be evolved for recruitment of Judges in India otherwise only selected persons will be able to be appointed as judge. Why do only people from some selected family become judge?

Wednesday, October 29, 2008

Impeachment of Judges in India


Hello countrymen,
The letter of CJI has triggered the debate on impeachment process.
Here are the constitutional provisions with regard to impeachment of judges of higher judiciary.

IMPEACHMENT OF JUDGES
(REMOVING JUDGE IS MORE DIFFICULT THAN THE GOVERNMENT ITSELF)
The letter written by the CJI (Chief Justice of India) to the PM seeking his intervention in initiating impeachment proceedings against a sitting Judge of Calcutta HC, has triggered a debate again regarding corruption in higher Judiciary and its impunities. We have seen removal of Governments and PMs so many times, but removal of HC and SC Judges has not been so far heard after the Constitution of India came into force in 1950. Independent India has however witnessed one impeachment, when Justice Shiv Prasad Sinha of Allahabad High Court was removed by the then Governor General of India, C. Rajagopalachari in 1949 on the recommendation of the Federal Court. Reasons for this situation are simple, the impunity given to the Judges in the Constitution. 
The corruption in higher Judiciary and disciplinary action against the HC and SC Judges has again become talk of the day following the unprecedented move of the CJI K.G.Balakrishan in which he directly wrote to the PM that Justice Soumitra. Sen, sitting Judge of Calcutta HC be removed for his ‘Misconduct. The CJI has given detailed information about Justice Sen’s misconduct when he was appointed receiver by Justice A.N. Roy in Steel Authority of India vs. Shipping Corporation of India case in 1993.
The three Judge panel comprising A.P. Shah C.J of Madras H.C, A.K. Patnaik, CJ of MP HC and R.M. Lodha of Rajasthan HC inquired into the charges levelled against Justice Sen and found them true. The panel submitted its report in February, 2008. On March, the 16th, the Collegiums of the apex Court comprising of CJ himself, J.B.N. Agarwal and J. Asok Bhan asked Justice Sen either to resign or to opt for voluntary retirement, but the unrelenting Judge refused to comply with, which forced CJI to resort to this unprecedented move. The move is unprecedented, because neither there is any provision in the constitution about such recommendation nor before this, any CJI has taken such ‘extreme step’. In fact Article 124(4) of Indian Constitution provides for removal of HC and SC Judges. This Article says ‘A Judge of Supreme Court shall not be removed from his office except by an order of the President passed after an address by each House of Parliament supported by a majority of the total number of membership of that House and by a majority of not less than two-thirds of the members of that House present and voting has been presented to the President in the same session for such removal on the ground of proved misbehaviour or incapacity.’ There is no separate provision for removal of HC Judges and Article 217(1)(b) provides for this and says ‘ a Judge may be removed from his office by the President in the manner provided in clause(4) of Article 124 for the removal of a Judge of the Supreme Court’. This is how the processes of removal of High Court and Supreme Court Judges are the same. The above Article of the Constitution provides for impeachment, whereas; Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968 determines the process of impeachment. 
According to this Act, the impeachment of a Judge can be done only by Parliament and impeachment can be initiated after a motion addressed to the President of India is signed by at least 100 members of the Lok sabha or 50 members of Rajya Sabha. Such is the process and such is the impunity. Such Judicial impunity has been conferred on Judiciary for the sake of its independence. The idea is perhaps taken from England. The above provision is similar to the rule prevailing in England, since the Act of Settlement, 1701, to the effect that though Judges of the Superior Courts are appointed by the Crown, they do not hold office during his pleasure, but hold their office ‘on good behaviour’ and the Crown may remove them only upon a joint address from both Houses of Parliament.
Any way the credit must be given to CJI, who could take such extra-ordinary step, because after all, extra-ordinary situation demands extra-ordinary steps. But unfortunately, the government was sitting over it as it was written two months ago and could only be known to public through media. This development has again triggered a debate on corruption in higher Judiciary and its overall functioning including the appointment procedure in the higher Judiciary. 
Before any debate on this issue, it should be clearly borne in mind that above cumbersome procedure of impeachment and other judicial impunities have been enshrined in the Constitution for making Judiciary independent. 
INDEPENDENCE OF JUDICIARY- the independence is guaranteed our Constitution and the concept has been borrowed from the US Constitution. Article III of US Constitution guarantees Indepenendece and Supremacy of Judiciary in United States. Independence of Judiciary is the tenet of Democracy and therefore; even Russian Constitution of 1993(Chapter-7 Section 120-122) also guarantees independence of Judiciary in Russia. In fact section 124 of the Russian Constitution says ‘Judges shall posses immunity and criminal proceedings may not be brought against a Judge except as provided for by federal law.
In India, this independence and limited Judicial Supremacy are enshrined in the Constitution and are expressed in (a) Methods of appointment of Judges (b) process of impeachment and (c) power of judicial review. Now, if all these provisions of the Constitution are analysed, inference can easily be drawn that the problems lay here themselves and so do solutions.
(a) APPOINTMENT- Articles 124 and 217 provide for appointment of Judges of SC and HC respectively. They clearly stipulate that the appointments have to be made by the President in consultation with CJI. The word ‘consultation’ has been always a matter of dissent and controversy. In fact, when A.N. Ray was appointed as CJ after superseding three senior Judges namely Hegde, Grover and Shelat, there were a lot of uproar in Judicial community including the Bar council of the apex Court. They argued that Judges have been superseded owing to their judgement in Keshavanand case (AIR 1973 SC) which went against the Government. Gradually the discretion of Executive in matters of appointment of Judges started diminishing. In 1993, a land mark judgment came from Supreme Court in ‘Advocates on record vs. union of India’ case. The apex Court ruled that the recommendations for appointment of Judges in HC and SC will be made by collegiums of three Judges and shall be in a way binding on the Government. After a ‘presidential reference’, the number in the collegiums was increased from three to five. This judgment was landmark because it took virtually all discretionary powers of the Executive in matters of appointment of Judges in higher judiciary. Thus the word ‘consultation’ became ‘concurrence’. Some people in legal domain argue that it was a dangerous development and was against the principles of the Constitution itself. How can a person or a group of persons appoint themselves which goes against the ideas enshrined in Article 311? They opine that there must be a transparent and justifiable procedure for such appointments. There are instances where persons from one family are becoming Judges for two to three generations. The judicial community of higher Judiciary is becoming an elite club of few ‘privileged families’. Candidly, it is not what ‘independence’ meant for.
(b) IMPEACHMENT- The process of impeachment as discussed earlier in this Article clearly indicates, that it is a cumbersome process and this is why in 50 years of our constitution not even a single Judge could be removed. In 1991, the impeachment proceedings for removal of Justice V. Ram swami could not be carried due to abstention of Congress party in the voting. The process of impeachment is laid down in Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968 which says that even if the motion is accepted, the presiding officer of the House has to constitute a three Judge committee to again inquire into the matter. After receiving the report, the motion will be put to voting, which requires 2/3rd number. Thus falling of Government (no confidence motion) which requires a simple majority only, whereas; removal of a Judge requires 2/3rd majority. That is why, it is truly said that it is easier to decide the fate of 100 billion people by way of forming and toppling Governments than removing a Judge. In our country, laws have sent many ministers and bureaucrats behind the bars on charges of corruption, but what to talk of sending Judges to jails, not even a single Judge has so far been impeached. Instances of corruption in higher judiciary are not unheard of. The ‘Transparency International’ in its report of 2007 has counted judiciary as the third most corrupt institutions in India, an inference totally in contrary to the common perception.
The former CJI Y.K. Sabarwal himself is in the eyes of storm for his judgements pronounced in ‘Delhi Sealing Case’, which allegedly benefitted his son. When a report in this regard appeared in one Newspaper, a suo motto contempt proceeding was initiated and the concerned reported was sought to be punished. The Contempt of Court Act, 1971, which itself is not yet codified, is another tool which sometimes is used to gauge the voice of dissent.
In another infamous case, Vigilance department of UP Police exposed misappropriation of 23 Crore rupees from GPF account of Class III and IV employees of Ghaziabad Civil Court. One of the accused arrested in this connection, made startling revelation that he has parted the money both in cash and kind, with one sitting Judge of SC, ten Judges of HC and 23 Judges of lower Courts. The investigation is not proceeding as Police cannot interrogate Judges without the consent of SC, though such protections are not given in Judges (Inquiry) Act. The matter is still pending with the apex Court and CJI has to convince the citizens of this Nation, as to whether there is equality before the law or not. Such corruption charges are often covered beneath the carpet in the name of Judicial Independence and impunity.
Names of two Judges of Haryana High Court figured in a case in which one law officer of Haryana sent Rs 15 lakh to them. Matter has been referred to CBI by the apex Court. List is long and result is dismally naught. 
It is easy preaching than done. The question being asked by common citizen that who will judge the Judges? Every one advocates for transparency and delegation of powers, but up to him only. CJI reacted sharply on provision of RTI Act by saying that it does not apply to them, as they are the Constitutional authorities. But the same authorities preach others about the benefits of RTI in detail and reprimands for not complying with the Act. Time has come to make introspection into the system so that the hope of millions of people of this country could be protected from being torn apart. 
REMEDIES:
1. The provisions of RTI should be made applicable to all components of functioning of Judiciary. Accordingly, suitable amendments in RTI Act, 2005 can be made.
2. The procedure of selection of Judges should be made more transparent and justifiable. Panel of Judges can be made well in advance before recommendation and be known to public by way of websites or media. Idea of setting up of a National Judicial Commission can also be made into reality, after all if you are required to go for a test for becoming a clerk, why does selection of Judges not require any test. An all India test might also be conducted to select Judges of Higher judiciary.
3. The Government is sitting over the Judges (inquiry) bill, 2006 for more than two years, therefore it should be passed, but before that necessary amendments are required, because the concept of ‘brother judges’ doing inquiry has proved ineffective if not futile.
4. The contempt of Court Act, 1971 be amended suitably, because healthy criticism of any institution is generally beneficial for the system itself in the long run. The Judiciary should prepare itself for listening to its criticism and bring about change by itself, a change though painful but helpful.

WHO FIGHTING FOR ITS EXISTENCE: WILL IT TRIGGER NEW ERA OF CONFLICT? Politics and lust for power are not endemic of India only...